The Charles Dickens Letters Project

To THE REV. GEORGE ARMSTRONG,1 5 NOVEMBER 1842

MS Gavin Adams.

London. 1 Devonshire Terrace

York Gate Regents Park. | Fifth November 1842.

My Dear Sir.

I have been greatly interested in the perusal of your letter, and am truly obliged to you for it. In all the sentiments you express, relative to the splendid abilities and high usefulness of the great Man2 whose death, in common with many thousands, we both sincerely deplore, I most heartily and thoroughly concur. And yet I cannot—believe me, cannot take upon myself the task of endeavouring, with my pen, to do justice to his honored memory.3

My reason for holding back, is plain and truthful. At this time my mind is necessarily employed upon another subject,4 which has taken full possession of it, and must hold it too, with God’s leave, for a long time to come. I could not, at such a juncture, do what I ought and would, with such a theme as Channing. And to do less than it deserves, would be a misery to me. Although I am well acquainted with his writings5 and hold them in as high esteem as you do, I really have so deep a sense of his immense usefulness in such a land as America, that I think I should, at the best, feel it almost presumptuous to write of such a man. But with the reason I have given you, to deter me, I feel that it becomes my duty not6 to enter the Lists in such a cause, and thereby exclude others who would serve it infinitely better.

Rely upon it that this is a wise and proper resolution, and one of which he himself, could he be judge in such a matter, would approve.7 I have been in frequent communication with him since I left America,8 and my book9 was on its way to him, when the news of his death was coming sadly across the great ocean. Those United States have as good reason to deplore the event, as his own loving family had, for it will be very—very—long before another such man rises up among them, to benefit the world. I can scarcely hope that you will agree with me just now, but in a little time I am sure you will. Awaiting it, I am My Dear Sir,

The Reverend George Armstrong.

Faithfully Yours

 CHARLES DICKENS

• 1. The Rev. George Armstrong (1792-1857); born in Ireland, graduated from Trinity College, Dublin, and ordained in the Church of England 1815. Resigned his Orders and became a champion of Unitarianism. Settled in Bristol 1838.
• 2. The Rev.William Ellery Channing (1780-1842; Dictionary of National Biography), Unitarian minister of the Federal Street Church, Boston, since 1803; acclaimed in both America and Europe as a man of letters and social thinker. CD and Catherine had breakfast with him in Boston, 2 Feb 42 (Pilgrim Letters 3, p. 31). News of his death was noticed in London papers, 1 Nov. See further Pilgrim Letters 3, p. 16n.
• 3. Armstrong wrote to CD, urging him “to seize this opportunity...for fixing the attention of the reading world, on both sides of the Atlantic” on that “most gifted of Christian teachers” (in R. Henderson, A Memoir of the Late Rev. George Armstrong, 1859; see Vol. III, p. 362 hn& n.2).
• 4. Martin Chuzzlewit, which CD had begun planning in summer 42 and which occupied him until summer 44.
• 5. There is no direct evidence of which writings of Channing CD had read. He possibly possessed Channing’s Discourse on the Life and Character of Joseph Tuckermann, 1841 (Pilgrim Letters 4, p. 720); Channing’s Works in 1 vol., 1840, was in the 1878 sale Catalogue of the Library of CD, ed. J. H. Stonehouse, 1935.
• 6. Doubly underlined.
• 7. CD overwrote the first three letters.
• 8. No letter to Channing after CD’s return from the United States is currently known.
• 9. American Notes. In Ch. 3 CD names “this distinguished and accomplished man”, so he might have “the gratification of recording my humble tribute of admiration and respect for his high abilities and character”. He emphasised Channing’s boldness in opposing himself “to that most hideous blot and foul disgrace – Slavery.”